owl

Articles and Research

Research on how gender bias can affect the quality of searches, tenure, promotion and peer review:

  • Exploring the Color of Glass: letters of recommendation for female and male medical faculty PDF

  • The Impact of Gender on the Review of Curricula Vitae of Job Applicants and Tenure Candidates PDF

  • Selected References on Stereotyping and Unconscious Bias PDF


Research reports and recommendations on gender equity in higher education:

  • AAUP Faculty Gender Equity Indicators 2006 link

  • An Agenda for Excellence: Creating Flexibility in Tenure-Track Faculty Careers (An American Council on Education and Alfred P. Sloan Foundation Report) PDF

  • Career Patterns of Women and Men in the Sciences, Sonnert, Gerhard, Holton, Gerald. American Scientist. Research Triangle Park: Jan 1996. Vol 84, Iss. 1; pg.63 (Available through Cornell University's Library Databases) [Sonnert and Holton discuss the results of Project Access, which studied in detail a sample of female and male scientists to determine both the degree of gender disparity in the average career outcome and the causes for the disparity.]

  • Motivated Stereotyping of Women Link

  • Casuistry and Social Category Bias Michael I. Nornton, Joseph A. Vandello, John M Darley. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Washington: Dec 2004. Vol. 87, Iss. 6: pg. 817 (PDF) [This research explored cases where people are drawn to make judgments between individuals based on questionable criteria, in particular those individuals' social group memberships. Authors suggest that individuals engage in casuistry to mask biased decision making, by recruiting more acceptable criteria to justify such decisions.]

Articles and commentaries on differences in perception and experiences of women in academe:

  • Women see less Clarity in Tenure Requirements than do Men Link

  • Where the Elite Teach, It's Still a Man's World Link

  • Nepotism and sexism in peer review PDF

  • Don't Just Search, Recruit PDF


Resources from Virginia Valian:

  • Creating Equity PDF

  • Why so Slow? PDF

  • Advancing Women: a Bibliography PDF

 

ADV logo

Pre-Recruitment

  • Cornell University's Academic Search Protocol PDF

  • Pool Development: identifying high quality candidates prior to the search PDF

  • Establishing an Effective Search Committee PDF

  • Sample Language for Advertisement PDF

Recruitment and Hiring

  • Planning the search PDF

  • Conducting the search PDF
  •   —Candidate Evaluation and Feedback Form (adapted from the University of Michigan ADVANCE program) PDF
      —Reducing Stereotypic Biases in Hiring PDF
      —Virginia Valian's guidelines for chairs on recruitment and retention PDF
      —Legal and Illegal Questions for Job Candidates PDF
      —Evaluating the search PDF

      Coffee with the Candidate: Please contact the ADVANCE staff to organize a meeting for your women candidates with other women faculty from across campus during interviews.

Best Practices in Recruitment and Hiring

    College of Veterinary Medicine:
  • Academic Search Process: Best practices now used in the College PDF

  • Affirmative Action Committee Charge PDF

  • Guidelines for Affirmative Action members serving on Search Committees PDF

  • Recommendations for Search Committees PDF

    College of Engineering:
  • Searches and Recruiting Guidelines PDF

    New Life Sciences Initiative:
  • Faculty Search Guidelines PDF


Useful links

  • Women in Science and Engineering Leadership Institute, University of Wisconsin Madison Link

  • General Search Tips: University of Washington Toolkit

  • Upstate New York Higher Education Recruitment Consortium Link

 

Back to RESOURCES page (link)